Is Self Righteous Anti-Hindu Bigotry the new normal for Indian Secularism?

Is Self Righteous Anti-Hindu Bigotry the new normal for Indian Secularism?

On December 6, 2010, a book titled “26/11 : RSS ki Sazish” (26/11: Conspiracy by RSS) written by Aziz Burney, who is the Editor-in-Chief of Urdu Sahara newspaper was released by Congress General Secreatary Digvijay Singh on in Delhi.

The book is about the attack by Pakistani terrorists on Mumbai which went on for 3 days – from November 26, 2008 to November 29th, 2008 – killing 164 people and wounding at least 308.  Targets were specifically picked up by the terrorists for maximum psychological impact and damage to certain communities.  For example, Leopold cafe, a place frequented by Westerners was attacked.  So was the Nariman House Jewish community centre!

Within hours, the conversations between the terrorists and their Pakistani handlers were intercepted and recorded.  One of the terrorist – Ajmal Kasab – was caught alive thanks to the courage of a police constable.  He revealed the details of his handlers – including Hafeez Saeed in Pakistan.

Despite the various loony extremist and fringe elements in Pakistani media making it a “conspiracy of the Hindu zionists (sic) – Pakistani Government and the top media group Dawn admitted that Ajmal Kasab indeed a Pakistani.  Not just that, Dawn TV went on to show how all the terrorists apart from Kasab – who were killed – were from Pakistan.

In fact the particular villages and towns to which they belonged were also revealed!

Ajmal Kasab[17] disclosed that the attackers were members of Lashkar-e-Taiba,[18] among others.[19] The Government of India said that the attackers came from Pakistan, and their controllers were in Pakistan.[20] On 7 January 2009,[21] Pakistan’s Information Minister Sherry Rehman officially accepted Ajmal Kasab’s nationality as Pakistani.[22] On 12 February 2009, Pakistan’s Interior Minister Rehman Malik asserted that parts of the attack had been planned in Pakistan.[23]

(Source: Wikipedia)

It is therefore indeed interesting that the General Secretary of Congress – a title within Indian National Congress which is at the highest level – was not just acquiescing to the conspiracy theory of the extremist Islamic loony fringe of Pakistan, but fully backing it up in an official capacity!  The salient points made in the book are:

  • The BJP and the RSS are responsible for 26/11 attack in Mumbai.
  • ATS chief Hemant Karkare was about to disclose many facts regarding Malegaon blast in which he was expected to expose many sadhus and saints including the BJP and the RSS. In fact, Karkare was not killed by AK-47 but by the service revolver of the police. RAW and Home Ministry are investigating the role played by the Gujarat ATS in Karkare’s murder case. Karkare was killed by Hindutva-minded police officials and people from the Chota Rajan gang
  • Mossad and CIA had assisted the Sangh Parivar in the attack carried out in Mumbai
  • Post 1993, all attacks in the country is the result of the nexus between the RSS and Mossad
  • The Congress is suspecting the involvement of the BJP in the Malegaon blast other than the RSS and Bajrang Dal
  • The RSS and Israel are trying to make India unstable (p. 190)
  • In order to make India a Hindu nation, such blasts are being carried out (p. 219)
  • While the RSS is distributing ‘Trishul’ to youths and women, the Bajrang Dal is providing training to people for making bombs and causing blasts. The VHP had planted bombs in several mosques in Maharashtra to explode them (p. 584)
  • The RSS and VHP are trying to defame Muslims by forming terrorist organizations like Indian Mujahideen and Islamic Security Force. Indian Mujahideen was not involved in the bomb blasts in Assam. Bajrang Dal is a dubious organization and Indian Mujahideen is the code name of it. Editor of Communalism Combat Teesta Setalvad mentioned in a report that the CBI is trying cover up Hindu Terrorism and Batla encounter was fake (p. 597)
  • Election Commission of India must consider banning the BJP to contest elections

If one looks at the above points, one realizes that this was unabashedly a Hate Campaign against the Hindu community and the Opposition Party of that time – Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) as well as its associates – that was attempted by the author and the Congress General Secretary.  By equating Hinduism in totality with RSS and BJP, and attacking Hinduism, and by association implicating BJP, Congress was running a whole religious community down! Given the vitriolic against the Hindus while cloaking the basic and inherent narrative as an attack on a political opposition party (clearly to argue plausible deniability) one wonders – Is Anti-Hindu Bigotry in India being sold in the cloak of Political opposition?

For, the inherent hatred against the common “culprits” – i.e.; Hindus, Jews and Americans – in the Islamic Terrorist Narrative across the world is too well known by now.  As is the instrument of Conspiracy Theories.  By juxtaposing the Big Three – Idolaters (Hindus in plain English), Jews and Americans – Islamic Extremists the world over instantly assign a Victimhood status to themselves and therefore, any act of terror is henceforth justified.

So, in the process of recruiting and training and justifying the Islamic Terror, two ingredients are paramount – Demonizing the “Big Three” and Self-assignment of Victimhood.  Conspiracy theories achieve both.  Congress did all of them and escaped the media wrath unscathed – without any explanation or questioning!  Such is egregious levels of media double standards! Alarmingly, the very people in India who forward the Islamic Extremist and Terror Narrative are considered “Secular”.

In fact, not only do they get the certificate of Secularism – but with that comes an unlimited right to express outrage at anything that is related to Hinduism – customs, Priests, rituals, Scriptures, language (Sanskrit), and Gurus or Teachers – in a way that really is structured to denounce Hinduism by association.

A critical question that one needs to ask and ponder upon given the above episode and the continued free pass given to Digvijay Singh, the Congress General Secretary and the Party itself is – Is Hinduphobia the real Indian Secularism?

AAP Victory in Delhi – an Open Invitation to Anti-Hindu Bigotry cloaked as Secularism

In the recent Delhi elections, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) was pitted against the incumbent BJP.  While AAP seeked the blessing and a special Fatwa by the main Mullah of the influential Jama Masjid mosque to vote for them, it was considered a communal act if any Guru with a large following even expressed any level of agreement with the ruling party.  None of the Gurus asked their supporters to vote for any party mind you.. unlike the Mullah of the Grand Jama MAsjid mosque.

But the Fatwa was somehow a “Secular” act in the increasing hypocritical political debate and landscape of India. What seemed like clear double standards and bastardization of the whole concept of Secularism prior to the Delhi Elections, became even more outrageously bigoted when AAP one.

This small representation of the election results has become common sight on many AAP supporters and self-appointed Secular people on Social Media.


Intelligent cartooning skills of the artist are more than well matched by his/her unbridled Anti-Hindu bigotry! Here is why:

  1. Swastika is probably one of two most sacred symbols in Hinduism.  It represents the Universal balance and oneness of the Existence.  No Hindu ritual, prayer, temple or new undertaking is complete without a Swastika!
  2. Swastika has nothing to do with BJP – the party that lost to AAP!  It is NOT something that BJP uses in any of the political works or undertakings.
  3. Swatika’s construction is considered to be its most important aspect.  If done wrong it is not only inauspicious but also derogatory.  That is why, when Hitler used the symbol facing left, it was considered to be a bad omen by the Hindus.  In each of the quadrants, there is a dot to balance the form.  The artist, to demonstrate his form of a man, has chosen to distort Swastika.

What one fails to understand is – When did political hatred for your opponent party become a good excuse to mock a religious symbol of the Hindus?


It gets more interesting because one of the partner parties of BJP also fielded candidates in Delhi – who incidentally lost.  That party is an avowedly Sikh party – the Akali Dal, unlike BJP, which has explicitly declared itself a National party working for all and having Muslims in important posts.  So the obvious question is – how come the Sikh symbol of Kanda was left out of those being chased out?  If one wants – turning the kanda around, and using it creatively – one can have a Sikh being chased out as well. The obvious question given the three issues with the use of Swatika (and Swastika alone!) is – was the Delhi Elections an elections against the Hindus?  Because the celebratory illustrations – so righteously shared by many on social media – does suggest so!

Or Is Self Righteous Anti-Hindu Bigotry the new normal for Indian Secularism?   Featured Image Source: Flickr

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Drishtikone - Online Magazine on Geopolitics and Culture from Indian Perspective.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.