Insightful newsletter of Drishtikone: Issue #280 - Is Yoga Hindu?

This is a debate amongst the Hindu Activists who have neither understood what Yoga is nor what Hinduism is. We will explore this question today in a very logical and dispassionate way.

Insightful newsletter of Drishtikone: Issue #280 - Is Yoga Hindu?
Priest, God, Caveman, Yogi, Trident, Indian Gods

Image by Drak Code from Pixabay

“The ultimate goal of all mankind, the aim and end of all religions, is but one—re-union with God, or, what amounts to the same, with the divinity which is every man’s true nature. But while the aim is one, the method of attaining may vary with the different temperaments of men.” - Swami Vivekananda

Subscribe now

Way back in 2016, on the International Yoga Day, in celebrations at the UN, Sadhguru led the function and answered a lot of questions of the dignitaries there.  Amongst the things he said were:

  • Yoga is technology.  Just as gravity is not Christian, Yoga is not Hindu.
  • Yoga is India’s gift to the world, it is no longer only of India.

After that event, one saw a multitude of “Hindu Activists” who have been fans of Rajiv Malhotra’s books and discussions start the abuse and denigration of Sadhguru and what he said.  That is because as per Rajiv Malhotra, shaving Hinduism context off of Yoga lends to its “digestion” by the Abrahamic forces.  He is right in one sense.  But he is missing the central point of difference between the nature and context of what Yoga is and what religion is.

And, since then, this debate and discussion have become more and more acute.  As the ability to outrage increases, the requisite investment in self-contemplation keeps decreasing.

Along with the abuse that happened yesterday because of that clip, this is another jibe that many “Hindu Activists” take at Sadhguru.

Let us explore.

Making of the Vedas

In Chapter 9 of Bhagwad Gita, when Arjun asks Krishna the fundamental question “Who are you?” Krishna explains his complete expanse.  He says something very interesting.

अहं क्रतुरहं यज्ञ: स्वधाहमहमौषधम् |
मन्त्रोऽहमहमेवाज्यमहमग्निरहं हुतम् || 16||
पिताहमस्य जगतो माता धाता पितामह: |
वेद्यं पवित्रमोङ्कार ऋक्साम यजुरेव च || 17||

One commentator (Source) has translated it thus:

It is I who am the Vedic ritual, I am the sacrifice, and I am the oblation offered to the ancestors. I am the medicinal herb, and I am the Vedic mantra. I am the clarified butter, I am the fire and the act of offering. Of this universe, I am the Father; I am also the Mother, the Sustainer, and the Grandsire. I am the purifier, the goal of knowledge, the sacred syllable Om. I am the Ṛig Veda, Sāma Veda, and the Yajur Veda.

Krishna is explaining that not just the rituals one does but the yajnas one engages in, including the offerings and the fire that go into creating the foundation of the effort, are ultimately Krishna himself.

The action, the actor, and the result are within the realm of the field of consciousness that Krishna is.

Of this Universe, the existence if you will, he is the father, the mother, the sustainer, and the grandfather.  He, as in the Universal Consciousness, was the origin, sustainer, and the very purpose of existence.  He is Aum he says and the three Vedas - Rig, Sam, Yajur as well.

Now, in these two verses, what is the one thing that seems completely odd to you?

He is everything - as in the universal consciousness, but he forgot part of himself?  He forgot Atharva-ved!  He surely would have been educated in it to know that there are four Vedas.

Every "Hindu activist” and educated Hindu knows it!  Isn’t it strange that Krishna forgot it?  Huh!!  How is that possible?!

But he keeps repeating the same thing in another verse.  When he talks of the fruits of Vedas.

त्रैविद्या मां सोमपा: पूतपापा
यज्ञैरिष्ट्वा स्वर्गतिं प्रार्थयन्ते |
ते पुण्यमासाद्य सुरेन्द्रलोक
मश्नन्ति दिव्यान्दिवि देवभोगान् || 20||

Three Vedas.

Krishna was neither forgetful nor ignorant.  He was the greatest authority on Shrutis and possibly the greatest socially engaged Yogi in Dharmic history.  No other Yogi did the “show-and-tell” Yoga the way Krishna did.

So, he knew what he was saying.

The truth is that there were only three Vedas by his time.

Atharva Veda had not been codified nor shared by anyone.  There were no recitations, no shlokas, and no Ved-paathis for Atharva by then.

Then how did Atharva just spring out of nowhere?

The knowledge.

Knowledge of Atharva preceded the Veda.

When Krishna likens himself to all knowledge and all yagnas, he is the manifestation of Atharva as well.

Atharva was there in Yogic energy form.  It became a Veda later.

That is how every Shruti was.  Shruti is eternal, not because you and I say so.  But because it is inherent in the source of this existence. It is the intelligence in the quantum wave that makes it consciousness and not just an inert energy.

It is brought into sound form by those who touched the source.

Even when none of the Vedas were, the Shrutis existed in the source.  Even when all mankind is gone, it will.  If tomorrow this planet, and even this galaxy is gone, the Shrutis will exist.

They are not a function of humanity or our brains or minds.  They are the basis of this existence.

Those Yogis who worked hard enough and were honest enough to work through the entire set of questions that define our identities and create the cloak of ignorance were able to delve deep into themselves down to their quantum existence to touch that realm where the Truth could be experienced - the Quantum/Consciousness level.

What they said, was a representation of what they saw, but it was not the complete experience of the Truth at the Source that was experienced.

It can never be.  No word is.

When, what was experienced, had to be broad-based, a need was felt to create methods and tools to help people have a glimpse of the Source.

Those tools became the yagnas, the rituals, the practices, and the schools of knowledge.

The path to access the Source, however, was Yoga.  Tools were a means to bring Yoga alive in people’s life and move along a path in that journey.

That path called for supreme sacrifice of one’s self.  There is no other way.  You cannot bluff your way, recite your way, or sing your way through to it.

You need to enhance your consciousness in such a way that even when you resonate with the bridge that links you to the source, the bridge doesn’t break.  Your physical form still remains so you can straddle both the physical (Newtonian) and the consciousness (Quantum) world at the same time.

The Swayambhu and the Rest

In the Yogic path, however, there has been only one Swayambhu. One who attained to on his own.  Through his own way and work with no lineage and no guide.  He was Shiva.

Rest everyone, including Krishna, Ram, Parashuram, and the Saptarishis had a Guru whose lineage goes back to Shiva himself.

So let us take Atharva Ved as a case study and understand this.

Shiva, the Swayambhu, attained to the Source and embraced the infinite in its completeness.  He shared that with his disciples (the Saptarishis) and the lineage of sharing the experience via various methods and paths was laid out.  One of the paths led to Krishna, via his Guru Sage Sandipaani.

As of the time of Mahabharat, Krishna had received only three Vedas in the word - oral - form.

The fourth, Atharva Veda, which became the basis of most yagnas and occult later was not part of the word form of knowledge.  Until then.  Its components were, however.

What is not in the word or ritual form is absent for the society.  The culture has not imbibed it as yet.

Not so for the Yogis, who do not care for the words anyway.  For words, in terms of the meaning they purport, are inconsequential in the existential reality.

Now, let us go to Hinduism.

What is Hinduism?

Is it doing Yagnas?  Or is it singing like Meera?  Or is it being an Aghori?  How about just sitting quietly (maunvrat) on a mountain for months on end?

What is it?

It is all of these.

For all of these are methods that were intertwined in our lives by those who were guided by their Gurus and lineage based on what was experienced from the Source (Yoga).

The intertwining of Yogic experiential learning codified as methods in everyday life such that it gives rise to a mass and broad-based culture of awareness, acceptance, seeking and well-being is the process of creating a cultural ethos that was known as Hinduism.

The rituals, the Vedas, the shlokas did not give rise to Yoga.  Yoga gave rise to them.

Yoga has no alliance nor any brief from any of the Vedas.

Just as Krishna did not care two hoots for Atharva Veda in Gita.

You know why?  Because there was NONE!

Similarly, there would have been a time when there was no Samved in word (oral) form.  Ditto for Yajur.

And, surely the Yogis and Sages who codified the Rig Veda, did not read it before codifying it.

They experienced it!

Rig Ved was the CONSEQUENCE of Yogic accomplishment!  Rig Ved did NOT CREATE Yoga.

In that sense, no Yogi ever went about seeking Samved. Or Yajuv Ved.  He went seeking the Truth.  For Truth is the only thing worth seeking.  If anyone had gone “seeking Samved”, he would have attained to something but not Moksha.  For Samved is a component of the universal consciousness.  That is why Krishna calls himself Samved as well.  But he is not just Samved.

A sliver of the existential Truth is codified as Samved.  Samved is NOT the complete Truth.  It cannot be.

Krishna as the embodiment of Truth was already there before a word of Atharva Ved was codified.

Let us contemporarize this.

Contemporarizing the discussion

Yoga is the fundamental science of existence.  Fundamental Science as in the fundamental physics.  Let’s just take one part of that physics.  Say, the Quantum.  What Schrodinger or Bohr were doing was research in fundamental science of the Quantum.  The principles and the knowledge that out of what they and the latter physicists uncovered gave rise to physics, some of which was used in smartphones and GPS.

Now, let us suppose that amongst the smartphone technologies - Android vs Apple, the latter would have utilized the results of the fundamental science in Quantum but Android would have steadfastly refused to - “because it is from a Satan”.

If some years from now, you had to explore Quantum insights, you could only turn to Apple technology.  Android technology, by design, would be bereft of any Quantum components.

If all fundamental science was lost and only Apple and Android technologies remained and someone wanted to explore Quantum, then reverse engineering and contemplating on the Apple algorithm may well be the only way left.

The only door.  The only repository.

That door.  That repository.  For Yoga, is Hinduism.

Hinduism did not make Yoga.  Yoga’s insights and experiences enabled a culture that came to be called Hinduism.

If Yoga is fundamental science, Hinduism is an application.

So were Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism, Shintoism, etc.  Some still are.

These all are offsprings of Yoga.  Yoga is the mother.

If Yoga is Einstein, then Hinduism is Steve Jobs.

Yoga, therefore, is not just not Hindu.  It is not anything.  For, it is everything!  The action, the actors, the offerings, and the results.

Hinduism is the only real door to Yoga though

On the other hand, Hinduism is probably the only repository of Yoga now.

The Abrahamic religions have by design defined themselves as an anti-thesis of whatever is Yoga.  For example, read these:

So, remember our example of Quantum Physics and smartphones?  Hinduism is Apple.  Abrahamic faiths are the Android.  You will not find your path to Yoga if you were to go searching the theology that has been custom created by those who not just actively opposed to Yoga but have an ethos that is anti-thesis of Yoga from the ground up.

The only reason why Buddhism did not survive for very long in India the way it did in the Far East was - because it was built upon components of Yoga.  Every generation of Gurus and Sages has done what Buddha did.  He was uniquely brilliant.  But he was one of many.  That is also the reason why the Sikh politicians have worked very hard to construct a narrative for Sikhism that makes it anti-Hindu now - over the last few decades.  The reason - they have seen how the components of the larger whole remain in real terms by looking at Buddhism.  So, in that sense, what was built upon the foundation of Yoga has over the last few decades been converted into an anti-thesis of the basics of Yogic practices.

Buddhism in the Far East, where it is still a spiritual practice, as opposed to a political narrative in India, is another door and repository of Yoga.  Albeit a limited one.  Sadhguru has explained it in one of the videos.

So, is Yoga not linked to Hinduism?

The heck it is!

Hinduism remains the only real door from where people can still enter the realm of Yoga.  But Hinduism did not create Yoga.  Yogic principles when intertwined with the social ways created a cultural ethos that came to be known as Hinduism. Because everyone who followed those ways was a Hindu in this land that everyone realized was ‘India’!

How Atharva Vedas was included:

It was Vyasa who, along with Mahatharvan, another great sage, convinced the community to include the fourth Veda – the Atharvana Veda – on the same level as the other three Vedas. The Atharvana Veda deals with the occult sciences or the science of manipulating energies to make things happen in the world. The Vedic traditions had rejected this and were not willing to include Atharvana Veda as a part of the sacred four. There were only three Vedas and the Atharvana Veda was rejected by the larger community because people tended to misuse it. But there was nothing wrong with the science itself. It is the way it is used that matters. Vyasa said the science need not be banned simply because a few people misused it. With that understanding, he made sure that the Atharvana Veda was given the same status as the other three Vedas which were already established as sacred books. (Source)

market corner: 10 quick bytes

  1. RBI Monetary Policy: Repo rate steady; 10-yr yield may remain in 6-6.20% range in Apr-Jun quarter of FY22 - more
  2. Mukesh Ambani India's richest in Forbes list, followed by Gautam Adani - more
  3. Goldman-backed ReNew to invest $9 billion on India’s green push - more
  4. Boeing predicts 2,230 plane deliveries to India by 2039, sees air travel revive by 2022 - more
  5. Cash withdrawal and interoperability – RBI proposes these for full-KYC PPIs - more
  6. Decoding RBI's new digital payments moves and their impact on the fintech ecosystem - more
  7. RBI raises Paytm, wallet accounts limit to Rs 2 lakh; opens RTGS, NEFT connectivity with payment operators - more
  8. Government approves production-linked incentive scheme for air-conditioners, LED lights - more
  9. Walmart’s Flipkart is said to aim for IPO in the fourth quarter; valuation may top $35 billion - more
  10. Banks sanction Rs 15 lakh crore under Mudra Yojana in last 6 years - more

nota bene

Migrants’ nightmares: As Maharashtra witnesses a resurgent second wave of COVID-19 outbreak, with daily coronavirus caseloads touching a new high, there is a palpable sense of panic set in among the migrant population that was arguably the worst-hit by the pandemic when it started in March last year. There is growing anxiety among the migrant labor in the city as they queue up at various bus stands and railway stations to board buses and trains to get back to their native places before the imposition of an inevitable lockdown.  (Source)

Mullah Imran: Pakistan rights campaigners have accused Prime Minister Imran Khan of "baffling ignorance" after the former playboy cricketer blamed how women dress for a rise in rape cases. In a weekend interview on live television, Oxford-educated Khan said an increase in rapes indicated the "consequences in any society where vulgarity is on the rise". (Source)

US boycott of Beijing Olympics: The Biden administration has floated the idea of a joint boycott of the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics as a protest against the human rights violations inflicted on Uyghurs in China's Xinjiang province, South China Morning Post reported. A boycott by the US in coordination with Washington’s allies “is something that we certainly wish to discuss,” US State Department spokesman Ned Price informed reporters. (Source)

Google AI’s Racist troubles: In the continuing fight against racism in the tech giant, Google researcher manager Samy Bengio has resigned from the company, a little after his colleagues questioned diversity in the company.  Bengio has resigned after a couple of his colleagues put down their papers to protest against the firing of artificial intelligence researcher Timnit Gebru. Bengio is the highest-ranking employee to leave the tech giant. (Source)

Now, ISIS Cloud: An ISIS-supporting cybersecurity group launched their own cloud and chat platforms that they vowed would help churn out new propaganda and allow followers of the terror group to better “close ranks” online. “In light of recent developments in the media arena and the restriction of technology companies to content, we resorted to developing solutions that provide a space for propagation between the fellow supporters and the general Muslim community, so that the benefits may prevail,” the Electronic Horizons Foundation said in its announcement posted online. “We developed the ‘Horizons Cloud Platform’ for advocates to use to upload and publish files on the Internet.” The group also developed an Element-based messaging and chat hub “to provide publishing rooms and continuous follow-up for news and content as an initiative to close ranks, and a starting point for the development of media work, Insha Allah.” (Source)

video corner: Delhi-Mumbai Expressway

The Delhi-Mumbai Expressway is going to be the most life-changing infrastructure event in India.  It will be what the highways in the US did.  Along with the other highway projects, it will create an India that will be unrecognizable within the next 10 years.

The 8 lane greenfield Delhi-Mumbai Expressway will be the longest expressway in India and is being constructed at a record pace. It will reduce the commute time by half and reduce CO2 emissions by 85cr kg or equivalent to planting 4cr trees. Here is a glimpse of the latest updates on the project.

Today’s ONLINE PAPER: Check out today’s “The Drishtikone Daily” edition. - THE DRISHTIKONE DAILY

Nuzzle Tweets “newsletter” - with tweets and stories that we read and follow in a day in one compilation on a daily basis - Nuzzle Drishtikone - just another way to keep up with things

SUPPORT DRISHTIKONE: If you consider our work important and enriching and would like to contribute to our expenses, please click on the button below to go to the page to send in your contribution. You can select the currency (for example, INR or USD, etc) and the amount you would like to contribute. Contribute to Drishtikone

If you like this post - please share it with someone who will appreciate the information shared in this edition

If you like our newsletter, please share it with your friends and family

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Drishtikone - Online Magazine on Geopolitics and Culture from Indian Perspective.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.